WOW!! We are so glad we were able to experience the wonderful food and service at The Guild whilst holidaying from Melbourne. From the minute we walked in the service... read more was second to none. The food came out promptly and was fresh and delicious. Stefano was so lovely taking time to speak with us at the end of our meal and we can see his passion for true Italian food. We will definitely be back and thank Stefano and his staff for a wonderful evening. 10/10!!!

  Italian spectacularly reinvented - Without hesitation THE BEST Italian meal I’ve ever experienced. Beats Norton St, Lygon St, the lot. Every dish is reinvented in unique and stunning ways. Fabulous Negroni to kick off,... read more and a great wine list. The oysters and scallops were so stunning that we were surprised that the mains could compete - but the risotto with beef and walnuts was insanely great, and the seafood spaghetti was on a galactic level. Then the tiramisu. Had them all? Then try this one. Geez!
Milton is privileged to host this talented team, delivering just stunning dishes. Oh, and there’s pizza too

  This restaurant is part of a growing trend of really good restaurants in regional areas. However, this one really sticks out from the crowd. Fresh, cooked to perfection and lovely... read more service. A real slice of Italy, loved it. I was particularly impressed with the wine list - someone has obviously given this a lot of thought. And all reasonably priced considering the quality. As a postscript: I loved reading the negative reviews of this place - they were so funny (and so far off the mark!).

  Amazing food in a cute town - Passing through Milton area we stopped in for dinner on a Monday and enjoyed delicious gourmet Italian - pizza and pasta were both incredible. Fantastic personal service too. So good... read more we went back on Tuesday night too! Thanks Stefano and crew.

  A must if you are in Milton - As a local for 6+ years it is my shame to report I have just been here for dinner.

The really enjoyed my meal here, the food was... read more fabulous the chef was engaging and helpful. The wine we selected was great. The company also very good.

You must go here if you can. A very different engaged approach to dining.

  We Felt like a good dinner and a good red after a lovely day on Burrill lake and up Mt Bushwalker, and then found this awesome little place, to celebrate... read more a special night out, and Stephan welcomed us like he’d known us half his life! Fantastic staff, healthy delicious food, wines, and warm atmosphere. ( This little place is up for sale- and new owners will have no regrets )

  The Spaghetti tonight was to die for… Thankyou!!!!!! - Wowowowowowwwww!! Passing through from up North, this divine little coastal gem served me up possibly the best, truly Milanese handmade spaghetti I’ve had out of Italy.
The pizza was light,... read more crisp and utterly delicious too.
We met the owner Stef tonight, so lovely and so rare to meet people in F&B who create experiences and cuisine at such a high standard out of passion and commitment to caring about people. Bravo and thanks guys for the most utterly delicious meal.

  Couldn’t recommend The Guild more highly. The food is authentically Italian & beautifully fresh and well presented. The service is outstanding - the staff went out of their way to... read more accommodate us sans reservation on a very busy Saturday evening. Went back for a second time and couldn’t fault them again. What a treat!

  Absolutely the best meal you will ever have - We spent Christmas at Milton with family and ate at Bannisters (see review) and at
TheGuild. I can say that the food at The Guild was half the price as... read more Bannisters and
twice as nice. I had lamb which was beyond tender and from local producers.
My husband had spaghetti. bol which was delicious and our friends had duc
which they said was sensational and spag. marinara which was loaded with every
kind of sea food. The owner was friendly being a local and welcomed us warmly
and the decor is interesting and elegant. However the coup de gras. is the
food which is just amazing and compliments to the chef...Italian I think.

  So good I wanted to cry! - Our extended family of 5 plus their 7 friends dined here 3 times over 2 weeks with a mix of family & friends on different occasions & every person loved... read more everything!!! Cannot fault this place. Everyone who works there is happy to be of service & proud of their offerings. I usually eat gluten free however due to the nature of the flours used & the cooking process etc I tried both carbonara & the truffle pizza ( I’m not a pizza fan usually). I am planning to order the truffle pizza again tomorrow it was that good. Do yourself a favor & book or grab take away if you. You won’t be disappointed.

  Without hesitation THE BEST Italian meal I’ve ever experienced. Beats Norton St, Lygon St, the lot. Every dish is reinvented in unique and stunning ways. Fabulous Negroni to kick off,... read more and a great wine list. The oysters and scallops were so stunning that we were surprised that the mains could compete - but the risotto with beef and walnuts was insanely great, and the seafood spaghetti was on a galactic level. Then the tiramisu. Had them all? Then try this one. Geez!
Milton is privileged to host this talented team, delivering just stunning dishes. Oh, and there’s pizza too

  My girlfriend and I have been to Italy several times, and we could easily say that this is probably our best Italian experience in terms of cuisine and friendly atmosphere.... read more
10/10 would recommend.

The owner was so accommodating, friendly and passionate.

The food was outstanding! So fresh, excellent quality and wonderful service!